Forget my previous want for the Sony Ericsson W950i, I think I'm gonna try and get the Orange SPV M3100 this weekend. It basically seems to be a new version of my O2 mini, with all the niggles fixed and some great new tricks added.
A couple of bits had been nagging at me with the W950i while I waited for its release, largely the fact that it runs on Symbian OS rather than Windows Mobile. The Nokia 7710 that I had before getting my current O2 XDA mini ran on Symbian and while it was quite good, I've really grown to prefer Windows Mobile over it. Windows Mobile just seems to work better as a PDA OS to me (though I do think the 7710 probably had some PDA bits pulled out) and one major factor is that I have TomTom for Windows Mobile. If I got a Symbian phone I'd have to buy a new copy of TomTom. That's more a gripe at TomTom for not allowing/providing software for both on the same discs, but it's a big thing anyway.
The W950i also lacks a camera. At first I didn't really think that would bother me, but then when I thought about the number of times I've taken quick snaps with my phone because I didn't even have my little IXUS with me, it was also going to be a miss. It's a shame as the W950i looks like it's had a camera area designed and kept out, probably to release a higher model later or to prevent it being an uber-phone and making the 990i pointless. The 2mp camera on the M3100 should do nicely as the 1mp job on my o2 mini is a bit iffy. The M3100 tops it off with a second front-facing camera for video calling. Both the W950i and M3100 are 3G phones, but only the M3100 will do video calls and they thankfully haven't skimped, as many 3G phones seem to, by making you turn the phone round to use a single camera on the back and then stopping you seeing the person you're talking to. Now I just need to find some friends with 3G camera phones :D
Both phones have a touch-screen (something I've got very used to with the Nokia and then O2 mini) with stylus and the M3100 also seems to have a selection wheel like the Sony jog-dial, but I haven't found out exactly what it's for yet. The M3100 tops things off with a slide-out QWERTY keyboard for writing messages, documents, etc. which should be great.
The M3100 has a very similar set of keys on the front to my O2 mini, with two added. The Sony uses the new fashionable touch-sensitive keys which seem to be turning out to be more style over practicality judging by people's experiences with them on other new phones. They look a nice gimmick and certainly aid the aesthetics, but if they're gonna be too easy to activate by accident then I won't miss them.
Next plus for the M3100 is wi-fi. It's one major thing I was disappointed not to have on the O2 mini so it's great to see it on the M3100. Find a wi-fi hotspot and you can get online with the wi-fi either for free or for whatever rate the hotpsot charges. It should also make for quicker synchronisation with PCs.
The major bonus the Sony has over the Orange is it's 4GB built-in storage. I don't imagine a 4GB microSD card will come cheap for the M3100, but then if I'm honest I don't feel the need to listen to my music that often when away from a computer. A very quick check found a 2gb microSD for £53 which ain't cheap, but I can leave that until later when I have a bit more cash. A 1gb card is about £26 which would probably do me fine to be honest.
So all the above, plus the fact I can get the M3100 now and probably some stuff I've missed, is why I'm going for the SPV M3100. Hope my little comparison is of help to someone else - it's just how I've weighed up the pros/cons. Who knows, when I get an M3100 in my hands it might feel horrible, but based on my O2 mini, I'm pretty confident it's the phone for me.
Looks great, I've had a bad experience with my first Windows Mobile Phone, Xda 2i(IIi) on my O2 contract. Basically it was a pda with a phone tagged on the end. Found it almost useless as a phone, dropped calls all the time and was too big to carry around. So after a few months I've ditched it for a Sony Ericsson P910i, which I bought off eBay. Since I previously had a Sony Ericsson phone which proved fantastic as a phone, I didn't want another disappointment. I still use the P910i today and is a great phone with some decent extras.
I really like having a phone with extra features so I don't have to carry around three to four different devices eg. mp3 player, pda and a mobile phone. I had hoped the Xda 2i would have coped with that, it really was only any good at being a pda, as an mp3 player it was rubbish aswell, it hogged all the resources and when there was someone calling it would crash. I did get it checked by O2 and they upgraded the ROM with newer software which helped, but after getting a smaller more reliable alternative I never looked back.
I know your Xda Mini has been great, wish I had got that instead of the 2i and TomTom works well with it. Will keep an eye out and see how you get on with it. My contract ends this Christmas :P
Yeah, reading reviews and comments of the Orange phone, the old XDAs seemed pretty notorious, but the new HTC Hermes (what the Orange M3100 is before Orange get their hands on it) has had nothing but rave reviews as far as I can see, especially noting better phone line quality and sound levels.
One complaint I have of my XDA II mini is that it's soooo quiet on normal phone calls and speakerphone might as well not be there, so looking forward to the Orange (just ordered online) and its reported better audio all round. Also, A2DP to go with my bluetooth headset :)
I wish I'd taken the plunge and ordered it earlier today now though as I could've had it delivered tomorrow. As it is, I tried to go and see it in the shops, none of which had it and now I won't get it until Tuesday.
Ah well, something to look forward to...
My Blog
or
Justifying My Rash Purchases
by Adam Perfect
Partly, but partly to give an opinion that others making the same choice can take or leave.
Just like I could say you only comment here to make cheeky remarks ;)
I don't deny it.
Your argument is flawed: nobody reads your blog.
where do you get tom tom software for the spv m3100,i thought that such software was only compatible with sybian phones...tell me all...and if my wishes do come through ...how does it work...feel free to add advice on car mounting equipment as well...
You can get a version of TomTom for Windows Mobile/Pocket PC which I was using on my old O2 mini. I've had trouble installing on the m3100 so far as the ActiveSync installer keeps crashing, but I'm now just copying the files manually and installing that way.
As I'm still setting it up on the m3100 (been busy ;p), I'll comment on how it worked with the O2 which uses the same OS, and it worked very well. It got me all around Europe, with the only real hiccups being some mental roadworks in Northern Germany (why don't continental Europeans provide diversions?) and around Reggio Emilia/Modena where they seemed to be re-designing the entire road network.
On car mounting, I did have a holder specific to my O2 mini (from expansys.com), but last time I looked no-one had made one for the m3100 yet so itd be one of those general clamp affairs.